Episode III boycott blues

As regular readers (all three of you) remember, I had sworn an oath to boycott Star Wars Episode III. My oath clearly got Lucas' attention, however my zeal was redoubled when the first title rumors leaked out ("A Creeping Fear" ?!?)

(OK, I admit that I thought Episode I was a masterpiece. You may discount my opinions from this point as your please. POD RACE!).

Now, however, I am in a bit of agonized indecision. My pride tells me to continue the boycott. There's still no hint that the original movies will ever be released in their original form on DVD. However, word is that the final movie is excellent. But that isn't the main reason I am rending my garments in confused despair.

The reason is that I had forgotten just what George Lucas has done for movies - the technological advancements that he pioneered and then literally gave away. One example is his digital animation technology, which he sold to Steve Jobs to become Pixar for a measly few tens of millions. Another is the creation of the software that eventually was bought for a similarly tiny sum - that became Avid editing software. The combined contributions to movie-making from Lucas-driven technology are immense - and all for the love of the art were they created, to remove as many obstacles from Lucas' brain to the screen.

In other words, Star Wars gave birth to modern film-making. And more. Lord of the Rings, Battlestar Galactica, and Finding Nemo all owe their success and magic crafted on screen directly to George Lucas.

I am humbled by the contributions Lucas has made to the entertainment medium of which I have always loved. But my pride still demands a boycott, because the original Star Wars films were the ones that captured my imagination all those years ago, and continue to lie at the foundation of my enjoyment of that medium today.

Background: Wired article on George Lucas

Also, here's the complete text of today's Houston Chronicle article on George Lucas's technical contributions to movie-making.

May 12, 2005, 3:38PM
Star Wars technology too far ahead for its own good
Associated Press

SAN FRANCISCO � After filming the first Star Wars movie with special effects far from special, George Lucas spent millions to develop a complete digital editing system to populate his sequels with armies of X-wing fighters and Gungan warriors.

Then, he virtually gave it away.

"We were 10 years ahead of the commercial reality," said Bob Doris, co-general manager of Lucas' computer division during the mid 1980s. "He inspired some very worthwhile ventures ... but the innovations weren't close to paying for themselves."

So Lucas sold many of his technologies for cheap � technologies that would later appear in home stereos, cell phones, medical imaging devices and virtually every Hollywood studio, driving billion-dollar companies and employing thousands of people.

Apple Computer Inc. chief executive Steve Jobs paid $10 million for the team that became Pixar Inc., and the movie company went on to make $3 billion at the box office.

And so it goes with Lucas, who was famous for saying "I'm not a venture capitalist."

Lucas recognized the absurdity of his situation as he made the first Star Wars movie. There he was trying to tell a futuristic story about intergalactic revolution, space travel and androids, and Hollywood was stuck using 50-year-old film-making techniques.

To create space ships or alien creatures, his artists built small models and hoped for audiences with vivid imaginations. The first "Death Star" was made out of plastic.

Lucas aspired for something much more grand, and after the first movie was released in 1977, he gathered a small group of computer artists and told them to spare no expense in creating a system that would include software capable of rendering images in three dimensions.

First, the computer team created "EditDroid," the first digital-editing system. It allowed movies to be transferred to computer disks so editors won't have to fiddle with cumbersome film reels. Lucas sold that technology to Avid Technology Inc., which went on to sell the forerunner of modern movie-editing bays.
Associated Press
Bob Doris heads Sonic Solutions, one of the companies to benefit from the innovations out of Skywalker Ranch.

Then he sold the computer division � later to become Pixar � to Jobs in 1986 in arguably one of the worst deals in movie history.

Using talent and technology that Lucas had let go, Pixar developed RenderMan, the software that has since transformed the film industry by infusing computer images with real-world qualities, such as shadows, glossy reflections, motion-blur and depth of field.

Emeryville-based Pixar used RenderMan in 1995 to release the first entirely computer-animated film, Toy Story, and then five more hits.

Other studios used RenderMan or software inspired by it to make the form-changing cyborg in Terminator 2, the massive waves in The Perfect Storm and even the computer-generated smoke and fire in the final installment of the six-film Star Wars saga, Revenge of the Sith, which debuts May 19.

In all, the software has helped studios win 33 of the past 35 Academy Awards for special-effects.

But Lucas � already financially secure because he owned the Star Wars franchise � had good reason for unloading some of the technology. Most of the editing and production tools were so advanced that there was little market for them at the time.

Also, he wasn't motivated by profits � he just wanted to make better films, said Doris, who left with three other Lucas staffers in 1986 to form Sonic Solutions, which makes DVD-creation software.

In fact, dozens of groundbreaking technologies were initially developed at Lucasfilm Ltd.'s San Rafael headquarters, known as Skywalker Ranch.

"Half the technology companies here are spinoffs" of a Lucas' company, said Robert Huebener, a former LucasArts videogame developer who in 1998 founded a competing firm in nearby Redwood City.

Perhaps not half, but the list of companies that in one way or another got their start at Skywalker Ranch is long.

Besides the Lucasfilm divisions Industrial Light & Magic for special effects, Lucasfilm for movie production, Skywalker Sound for audio post-production and LucasArts for video games, Lucas inspired Pixar, Avid and Sonic Solutions.

Other spinoffs include visual effects developer Visual Concept Entertainment, production studio Digital Domain and video game software companies BioWare and Nihilistic Software, to name a few.

Some of those companies found other applications for the technology developed at Skywalker Ranch.

THX, the theater sound system developed in 1983 and rolled out to more than 2,000 theaters across the country, is now in car and home stereo systems. Sound effects designed by Skywalker Sound's Gary Rydstrom are available on Apple computers. Before Pixar became a powerhouse in animated-movie making, the company sold computers that helped doctors create digital three-dimensional models.

Lucas may not have profited from this galaxy of businesses, but he's earned lasting respect and gratitude from his fans as well as many in the movie industry, said BZ Petroff, who oversees production at San Francisco's Wild Brain Inc. animation studio.

"Back in 1980s you'd have a director of photography on a crane performing incredibly complex and long camera moves going through these miniature sets," Petroff said. "Now, you have a 25-year-old getting the same shots on his computer."

Special effects had fallen out of favor in the 1970s when Lucas began the Star Wars saga, Lucas recalled as he promoted his final Star Wars movie last week. Some studios had dismantled their special-effects departments entirely.

"I'm most proud," Lucas said, "of the fact that I was able to take special effects out of the cellar."


Andrew said...

There was much greatness that Lucas did for movies, but he also had one fatal flaw. When people began telling him what a genius he was, he started believing them. A man who sets out to make a movie that's a bit of rolicking good fun will often succeed in spades, whereas a man who believes that he is a Brilliant Artist with a Grand Vision is going to lack the necessary humility to do something like hire a decent writer.

Jack said...

I have on VHS tape the original versions of the first three movies that were released, and upon repeated viewings of both versions, I cannot say that the changes really detract from the movies (other than Greedo shooting first!!!) in my opinion.

However, it is also difficult to demand someone release something that he apparently truly was not happy with, despite the acclaim they received.

In other words, there is a bit of a conflict here between sasifying the needs of the man who was the driving force (no pun intended) behind the creation of this modern mythology and those who want to recapture what they first saw in their youth.

However, I don't think Lucas deserves a lot of the flaming I see directed towards him (from elsewhere, not here!) for making his decision. They are indeed *his* movies, after all, even if he is now rich beyond *my* dreams of avarice because of the fans who have paid repeatedly for anything and everything associated with the films.

Jason said...

Well, I liked it. I'm sure you'll see it eventually.

I agree with your point about the original movies, though, and admire your sticking to your guns on this one.

Gohlkus Maximus

tweedledeetweedledum said...

This blog is awesome! If you get a chance you may want to visit this software engineering site, it's pretty awesome too!

jon said...

We are trying to find good movie download site to take the kids this weekend. Good movie download site reviews are hard to find

I just stumbled onto your blog while looking. Seems to happen to me a lot since I am a knowledge mooch LOL