Tariq Ramadan denied visa

Tariq Ramadan is a controversial figure - that much we can agree on. Invited as a lecturer at the University of Notre Dame, his visa was suddenly revoked by the request of the US Dept of Homeland Security. Ramadan is the grandson of the founder of the Muslim Brotherhood, a lineage which most zealous Muslim-phobes equate to support of terror. However, Ramadan's life work is to espouse a basis of Muslim identity firmly rooted in Western ideals, and has written a book called "To Be a European Muslim" detailing that philosophy.

It is likely that the enmity towards Ramadan, despite his explicitly moderate message of tolerance and inclusion of muslims within the political and cultural mainstream, stems from his unwavering critiques of Israel's human rights abuses towards the Palestinians:

"What I'm saying as a Muslim is that when I criticize a policy, for example the Saudi policy or the Egyptian policy, I am not Islamophobic," he said.

"And when I am criticizing the policy of the state of Israel, of [Prime Minister Ariel] Sharon, I'm not an anti-Semite. It's just a political criticism."

That's not unfamiliar territory to me. His (Israeli-hyper-partisan) detractors such as Robert Spencer insist that Ramadan is a closet anti-Semite, though Ramadan has explicitly denounced anti-Semitism as an alien import to the Muslim mindset, urging Muslims to take heed of the moral tragedy of the Holocaust.

It's a tragic irony that the muslims most critical in bringing about cultural change in the Middle East and elsewhere, the potential saving bulwark against the rising tide of extremism, are lumped in with those they denounce. The reason is their refusal to denounce being muslim itself. Apparently, the only "acceptable" muslim is one who rejects the Qur'an as a divine text, Muhammad SAW as a prophet of God, and adopts a secular-fundamentalist approach to their "faith". Some are comfortable with this, others are not - count me among the latter. Tariq Ramadan is a hero to me and others like me who will always be a muslim and yet will not cede our right to be counted among the Men of the West.

UPDATE: via Brian Ulrich, I just discovered the blog Chapati Mystery, which also addresses the Tariq Ramadan issue in a nice post with useful links to more info on him via Muslim WakeUp! and Abu Aardvark.


MikeNargizian said...

"Hyper Israeli Partisan"

Hmmmmmmm wonder what that has to do with his analysis?
I think he's one of the leading voices criticizing the fundamentalism in Islam on the net. But of course he's a "hyper Israeli partisan"..... boy you sound yet so much like that site in reverse comment's section you love to criticize............. lgf......

We know how much his "israeli partisanship" has to do with his criticism.... of course anyone who critiques Islam must be either a right wing Zionist (see Jooo) or an Israeli partisan.... lol...........

Thus, Charles Johnson must be the latter since he's not Jewish...
Further, Khaleel Mohammed debated Spencer and Ye'or and had respectful comments though he disagreed with Spencer for his knowledge and respect for Islam.


Rook said...

Tariq's views seem more in line with manifesting peace, not violence.

MikeNargizian said...

France even denied him entry? You think there's more there?
I don't know a lot about him. However, its possible/likely the US has more on him in intelligence surveillence than they can release?

Further, he may or may not be a "peaceful" guy that doesn't guarantee him the right to be able to teach at an American University does it?

Pipes wrote an article today about some of his links tenuous and not.
Also, just because this guy was denied entry it doesn't mean people are "trying to tell Aziz he can't be a Muslim".... that's way over the top, puhhlease.
Further, if you call Irshad Manji's critique of Islam, gentle and PC as it is, disavowing Islam, then can we can we compare the criticism Judaism and Xtianity receives from its liberal members? IT PALES IN COMPARISON...
Again, puhlease, with that nonsense. Thus, Islam and its practice doesn't need any reformation as Judaism and Xtianity prior underwent? If not than what's all the bogus talk of "moderates" and "reform"?

Also, Sami Al Arian's friends even till the last second defended him as a moderate intelligent guy.
It turned out that the FBI agents on the ground have been complaining for over a decade that one of the head terrorists linked to Hamas and Al Queda in the world was arrogantly operating right from University office in Florida. The bureaucratic heads kept squashing it because of Saudi pressure.

CMatt said...